26 August 2009

15Malaysia - Halal

Jackster say this film is rubbish, but I'll say it's an eye opener.

Some may found it's offense, but I think if this video was made in a non-muslim-majority country, it'll be an educated one.

I know it's stupid, and lack lots of information, but truly a great film from a non-muslim director and crews.

Read the comments, notice some of the non-muslims comments, and your heart will cry.



Official Site: 15 Malaysia - Halal

10 penghinaan diterima:

Jackster on August 26, 2009 at 8:23 AM said...

Salam alayk..

aah mmg aku cop video ni rubbish.

reason ?

silalah bukak link blog aku, bace post dgn komen ye.

Oh n nk quote ayat sorang yang komen kat video tu (dengan sdkt penambahan n pengubahsuaian),

"nak cakap pasal halal pada makanan tp tnjuk pmpn separuh bogel, dengan ayam yang tak pakai seluar, si penyembelih pula terselak kainnya sampai nampak paha! wow! n none of them has any significant meaning."

aku x heran nape org ckp video ni offensive.. tp aku ckp video ni rubbish, stupid n worthless.

Tapi,

aku tak paksa sape2 sokong aku, itu hak masing2, ada akal boleh judge sndiri.

oh n sdkt quote dari komen yg aku tules kat blog aku,

"it has a message, but message alone is not enough, you have to do it right."

Wallahua'lam

PEMENANG on August 26, 2009 at 10:32 AM said...

haha...aku setuju ngan denmak tapi aku setuju gak ngan jackisister? eh camne nih? aku setuju dengan dua2 sedangkan dua2 bertentangan pendapat......eh camne nih?

shairah on August 26, 2009 at 11:13 AM said...

i like. =D

all in it - that half naked ratu cantek, the quite 'offensive' chinese wit slit eyes and indian with black mask, i think they have their own meaning and served their own purpose. maybe it actually trying to portray how we malaysian love to stereotype things, like what they did in the video.i found it rather sarcastic than stupid.

i read the comment section, terkejut jgk rmai rupenye non-muslims yg selama ni xtau pon muslims ade cara sembelihan 'halal' yg tersendiri. the video is a bit 'ntah hape2' but i think it is quite informative for a non-muslim. rasenye komen yg plg bes skali is mcm mana we muslims might unintentionally offensed the hindus by slaughtering cows kt taman perumahan yg ade penganut hindu when they actually thought of the cow as one of holy-being.

overall message is quite straight-forward and simple -this is one of 15Malaysia videos, and 15Malaysia is about Malaysia so rasenye to show how muslims actually slaughter the livestock in a halal way is not too bad i guess.

HafizAdam on August 26, 2009 at 11:17 AM said...

you should read one of the comment yang membetulkan salah faham orang Islam tak boleh pegang babi tuh.

yg menarik, username macam Cina.
tersentuh seyh.

orang Melayu masih lagi anggap babi tuh hina, orang Cina boleh betulkan: babi boleh pegang, cuma kena samak.

komen lain?
sikap pekerja Melayu yang goreng daging dengan mee. pelanggan tak makan daging, dia suruh tuka tapi pekerja suruh letak tepi. pelanggan balas balik, masak babi dengan mee, pastuh asing kat tepi. korang makan tak?

haha best2. semalam bace sampai page 13. arinih nk sambung lg bace komen.

shairah on August 26, 2009 at 12:00 PM said...

owh ade? will check it out after this =D

btw adik dinmat, u got a videocam kan? kalo u x bz, tak rase nk join my malaysia ke? tdi i tgk dh 57. hehe~

HafizAdam on August 26, 2009 at 12:03 PM said...

my malaysia?
apekah itu?

shairah on August 26, 2009 at 1:03 PM said...

owh sorry i dont know what they called it actually. suke2 je letak name mymalaysia haha. basically u juz have to make ur own video, tema die malaysia la, then upload to youtube, tag it as '15MY' and if it is good enough, the 15malaysia team will put ur video in their website. juz klik kt link '57Malaysia' tu. i like video 'sama2' tu; agk typical la since die interview people kt street, but the feedbacks were quite genuine. die punye editing cam pening kepale sket nengoknye but d message is very strong. tibe2 tdi tpikir kalo u interested in making one if u got free time. hehe

Jackster on August 26, 2009 at 5:29 PM said...

wan, xde mslh pn stuju 2-2, perbezaan pendapat x semesti percanggahan fakta, mungkin 2-2 pendapat tu btol, kan ko gak yg aja aku hehe

btw shairah, kamu punye taste mmg unik, menarik =)

oranglidi on August 30, 2009 at 2:14 AM said...

adam, cite nurkasih lu dah xleh upload ke?? wa dgr cite tv3 da bg surat kat lu.

Anonymous said...

maybe vid ni nak perli mentaliti masyarakat melayu malaysia:

haram xde kompromi:
makan babi, binatang haram

haram kompromi:
ratu cantik, buka aurat etc

 

License

This blog by Muhammad Hafiz Adam is official website of Creative Designer and licensed under a Creative Commons Attribution-Noncommercial 2.5 Malaysia License.

You're free to Share (copying, distributing and transmitting) and to Remix (adapting the work) under the following conditions:
a) Attribution;
You must attribute the work by linking back to this blog pr anything similar (but not in any way that suggests that I endorse you or your use of the work).
b) Noncommercial;
You may not use this work for commercial purposes.

Categories

~AkuDarahAnakMalaysia~ Copyright © 2009 Community is Designed by Bie Blogger Template